A Slow Read: Richard Mabey’s The Cabaret of Plants
Among the things I promised to do in 2016 was reading longer books, as an antidote to my impatience and my growing inability to concentrate. I haven’t been doing too badly: in addition to quite a few other books, I recently finished The Silk Roads by Peter Frankopan, a proper doorstopper, and I’ve just closed Richard Mabey’s The Cabaret of Plants, an eclectic collection of essays on plants and their role in the world.
It is in fact not a very long book, less than 400 pages, but it’s a slow one. Although Mabey is a journalist, his writing style is poetic and byzantine, full of obscure words* and classic quotes**. I’m obviously not a native speaker of English, but I rarely experience difficulties when reading non-fiction in that language, as my passive vocabulary is sizeable (I do most of my reading in English). This book was often a challenge, however – not only because of the author’s love for complex syntax, but because my botanical knowledge is limited. I don’t really know my elms from my ashes.
Despite these challenges – and partly because of them – it’s a rewarding book. The complexity makes it rich in meaning, but still accessible for someone for whom plants are not a ruling passion. I love the title of the book and it’s an apt one: faintly Victorian (echoing another phrase that could have been fitting, cabinet of curiosities), somewhat carnal, contradicting the view of plants as something passive and boring – all prominent themes in the book. The topics covered are wide ranging, from the 19th century obsession with ferns to the hypothetical memory of mimosa; from the extraordinary construction of baobab trees to the botanic art of the East India Company. By a happy coincidence, Mabey touches upon several of my personal obsessions: the emergence of agriculture (I find it compulsively fascinating), glasshouses, headstrong females in pursuit of strange goals, waterlilies, and the already mentioned East India Company.
The book is carried by the author’s love and respect for plants, his insight into the vegetable world and by tantalising nuggets of knowledge scattered over the pages. Which country has the biggest number of oak species? What variety of apple inspired Newton to come up with the idea of gravity? Why did Linnaeus describe one plant as ‘nine men in one bride’s chamber, with one woman’?*** But unlike in most modern bestsellers, the fascinating knowledge is not presented in neat, bite size pieces, but is happily floating around in a cocktail of philosophy, memoir and general greenery.
It’s an old-fashioned book and that’s why I recommend reading it – slowly and mindfully, maybe just a chapter at a time, when the mood is right. Or if not this one exactly, read another book like it, on something you’re interested in. This review is less about the individual specimen and more about the species. I don’t want slow books to become extinct.
* Have you ever heard the word ‘guerdon’ before?
**I suspect that familiarity with and love for the great classic English poets would add another layer of enjoyment for the reader. As even my knowledge of Keats is abysmal, I could have survived with less speculation over what his views on pollination may have been. It is, in general, a very English book, despite its reach.
*The answers are, respectively: Mexico (with 160 species); Beauty of Kent; he was describing a plant via the set-up of its sexual organs, not a huge success in the 18th century.
This sounds really interesting in an intriguing sort of a way. I love plants and am painfully ignorant about them but carve greenery and wildlife so feel it would be good for me to learn more. I might red it in a chapter before bedtime way.
There is also, as you say, something oddly compelling about the title, it puts me in mind of slightly dark vintage Hollywood films. Who knows if that was his intention!
Yes, I find it works best if you read a chapter or two or three at a time (some chapters are very short, others are more like proper essays) and don’t try to breeze through it the way you would with a thriller or a lighter novel. But if you have an affection for plants, I think you will bond with the author 🙂
Sorry crave not carve – that really would be a weird one!
🙂 No worries. I’m the queen of weird typos.
This one is on my radar, and thank you for your thoughts about it.
I’m currently reading Edmund de Waal’s The White Road and enjoying it, but it does have some very slow bits. I am tolerating them in the same way that I would listen to someone dear to me expounding on something I have no interest in whatsoever.
Mabey’s a bit like that occasionally, too, but not too much. And my attitude towards these bits is very similar to yours (you have described it so well).
Great post! it sounds very attractive, I love plants, flowers, gardens…my mother used to walk me down the garden and name the various plants and shrubs and I remember most of them. That is why Jo Malone latest marketing works too well on me, Sorrel, Nasturtium…I may end up with the carrotty one.
Another longer book where plants (actually mosses) play a big part is Elizabeth Gilbert’s the Signature of all Things, 513 pages, but for me it was a fast (perfect holiday) read, and given the headstrong female main character I can imagine you liking it a lot. And it features a dog. Very unlike other books she has written (I bounced off those).
I think you might enjoy this and it’s a beautiful book. The recent Malones work on me as well, as I love herbs and approve of the concept of the collection enthusiastically. I smelled them last weekend and thought they were all nice, with the wild strawberry/parsley one being my favourite and the carrot number 2.
I’ve been undecided about reading The Signature, but if you approve of it, I will give it a go 🙂
What is your reservation about it? If you can elaborate a bit about it I may be able to assess if this is for you or not…I enjoyed it tremendously but I wouldn’t want you to regret 513 pages! Did you buy any of the Malones (not trying to get you to enable me or something…)
I’m mostly worried that it would be too much like Eat, Prey, Love. I did enjoy some parts of it, but I honestly read it just to know what the fuss was about. I’m by default suspicious of ‘spirituality’ and the need to travel to Asia to find oneself, etc.
I totally bounced off Eat, Prey etc. It gives me the creeps! Her Signature book is, apparently, very unlike the other stuff. There is some reference to Boehme (the title), but I wouldn’t classify his thinking as spirituality, at least not the Eat Prey and be happy kind. It is more of a great adventure, set in a very interesting part of history (Darwin, discovery expeditions, the hunger for knowledge and science etc), and in various parts of the world, and, maybe one of the reasons I liked it, the Dutch play a bit of a part too (not so flattering but interesting to read). There are some slightly more sexually explicit parts, but that is no problem for me, and I wouldn’t think for you too. Some reviews find it slow and boring, but I read it in one go (albeit on a sunbed!). I gave my copy away, if I still had it I would send it to you!
This does sound really good and no, I’m not bothered by explicit sex, unless there is too much of it and it becomes boring. I’m making my holiday reading list right now (off in a week!) and will include it, thank you.
Also, forgot to say that I haven’t bought any of the Malones yet, but I think I’ll get one. I did consider the entire coffret (I think J would wear some of those gladly, too), but am currently bankrupt and need to be reasonable.
I love your thoughtful response and comments. The thing that I like about Mabey is that he writes from a place of knowledge through observation and enthusiasm and in some ways follows the tradition of people like Gilbert White , Natural History of Shelbourne, which lends his writing a gentle, almost quaint, tone.. Keep up the reading and reviews please. Have you read Robert MacFarlane’s The Wild Places or Landmarks…also good and more ‘modern’ in voice.
Thank you so much, Kanuka! I must admit, I’m not well read in nature-related subjects, although I loved Gerald Darrell as a child and read everything by him that was available in Estonian. All recommendations are therefore especially welcome.