Scents of the Day: Part 2

Scents of the Day: Part 2


Last year, I did a project called Scent of the Day. For a month, every day, I talked about a scent on Facebook. I have been asked by friends to make these musings available on the blog, as it’s impossible to find anything on Facebook. So I’ll copy my mini-reviews here, but it needs to be done in batches – otherwise it’d be an insanely long post. You can find the first instalment here.

Part 2 is going to be all over the place: from an ultimate classic (Mitsouko) to a cheap thrill (Elizabeth Arden Green Tea) to modern opulence (Amouage Lyric) to a Scandinavian candle (Byredo Bibliothèque). My notes on availability are a bit – but not entirely – specific to Estonia, but I’ve kept them, just in case. I have to apologise for the pictures again, as they were random snaps for Facebook, but I’ve kept these, too, for reference and some amusement value. (The cover photo is new.)

2 APRIL
Scent of the Day: Mitsouko EdT (Guerlain)

Mitsouko

Yes, this picture of Mitsouko, the classic of the classics, the greatest masterpiece of Jacques Guerlain, was taken at Brussels Airport Duty Free. I don’t own a bottle (of which more later), but it’s impossible to leave Mitsouko out of the SOTD series, so I resorted to taking a hurried snap at 7AM this morning to the astonishment of the sales staff.

If you’re ever assaulted by a perfume snob who demands to know what your favourite perfume is and you don’t want an argument, I suggest you say Mitsouko. It is so revered by perfumers and perfumistas alike that you cannot go wrong. Everyone from Jean Harlow to Sergei Diaghilev to Lou Dillon was/is a fan of this iconic fruity chypre (there are wars over how to define a chypre, but let’s agree for the purposes of this review that it means a complex fragrance that includes at least the notes of citrus, oakmoss and labdanum). This may be the only piece of useful advice you get out of my posts, so I hope you appreciate it.

Despite all this love for Mitsouko, I think it’s oldfashioned and musty and difficult (that’s why I don’t own a bottle). At least this was what I planned to write – a rebellious review to defy the perfume establishment! A manifesto of wearing only what you like and not caring what others believe to be classy! Unfortunately, when I sprayed myself with Mitsouko this morning, I found myself not disliking it. And after the initial discordant burst that I still think is somewhat musty, I’m afraid I kind of liked it. For the first time – and I’ve tried Mitsouko many, many times – I could see what the fans mean by the golden glow of ripe peaches, and the slightly sweet drydown didn’t seem too sugary. I sprayed again in Helsinki and no change, Mitsouko was still enjoyable.

I don’t know, maybe it’s a new formulation that suits me better or maybe sleep deprivation somehow agrees with Guerlain classics or maybe I’ve grown into it. I believe Mitsouko to be an acquired taste for most people – don’t be fooled by me mentioning the peaches, these peaches are so refined that if they were real, you’d most likely feel unworthy to eat them. I stand by my words about only wearing what YOU like, but all perfumes deserve a second chance. And some deserve a third (and possibly 27th).

A note on availability: It’s not as bad as one would think. Kaubamaja has the EdT, as do many airports. The best place to try Mitsouko is of course the Guerlain flagship on Champs-Élysées, but then you should forget all about the EdT and try the parfum concentration.

3 APRIL
Scent of the Day plus a brief rant: Bibliothèque (candle, Byredo)

Bibliotheque

One of my main complaints about the perfume industry (and I’ve got legion) is its conservatism and backwardness. It’s not necessarily/only about the scents, but the image of them. Have you, for example, seen the bottle of Elizabeth Arden’s Untold? No? Lucky you. Most of the perfume ads make me weep with the feminist, intellectual and aesthetic pain they cause. Even niche brands tend to stick to a nostalgic or traditionally glamorous narrative.

It’s been getting markedly better in the last few years: mostly thanks to smaller brands, but there are some mainstream examples, too (Martin Margiela comes to mind). Byredo, a great Swedish brand, was one of the first in what I’ll call Modern Cool category and they still do it better than most. I love their simple, black-and-white aesthetic (the perfume bottles are starker than the candles), their focus on design and contemporary visuals and their innovative concepts for scents. Also, you should google Ben Gorham, the founder of the brand, you really should.

The only problem is that I don’t love any of Byredo’s fragrances. I like several of them – Pulp, Gypsy Water, Bal d’Afrique, the new Flowerhead – but not enough to buy a bottle. There is, however, one Byredo product I adore and you’ve probably guessed that it’s their Bibliothèque candle. First of all, it’s called Bibliothèque. This was enough for me to order the candle unsniffed, something I’ve never done with a fragrance. And it smells exactly like my fantasy library with leather armchairs, wooden floors, bouquets of violets and some plum liqueur in the decanter. The candle is of very good quality (as it should, for that price) and the throw is impressive.

A note on availability: well, Stockholm isn’t that far, is it? If you’re willing to blind buy (which I don’t recommend), the web site is an option. There is a full list of stockists on the web site, too, with London, Paris and Brussels represented, among others. (Edit: It is now available in Crème de la Crème in Tallinn as well).

4 APRIL
Scent of the Day: Green Tea Scent Spray (Elizabeth Arden)

Green Tea

I had a lovely conversation today with a lady who has been interested in and working with perfumes for decades. What struck me the most during our chat was her total lack of snobbishness regarding fragrances: she has access to many very expensive scents from exclusive brands, but she seemed thoroughly unimpressed by all that.

So, duly inspired, let me turn to one of my favourite perfume categories: cheap thrills. This category is sadly getting smaller by the day, as most brands constantly adjust their prices upwards. L’Occitane, for example, used to be great at affordable, nicely made scents, but many of its products have gotten pretty expensive. Roger et Gallet and Demeter still do a good job, but they are not easily accessible for many of you – and part of the concept of a cheap thrill is that you should be able to buy it whenever fancy strikes.

One of my reasonably priced favourites is, however, very widely available and that’s Elizabeth Arden’s Green Tea. I loved it before becoming a serious perfume nerd and I enjoy it still. To me, it smells less like a cup of Japanese tea and more like a glass of green ice tea with a slice if lemon. I’m afraid there isn’t too much else to be said about the smell, this is pretty much it – a straightforwardly nice spring and summer scent. You need to spray quite a lot, but that’s what cheap thrills are for.

A note on availability: as I said, this one is available almost everywhere. If you are in Estonia and don’t mind the atmosphere of Osturalli at Kaubamaja, you can have this for a very decent price at the moment. If you prefer your perfumes floral, try Green Tea Honeysuckle instead.

5 APRIL
Scent of the Day: Lyric Woman EdP and body cream (Amouage)

Lyric

As I’ve mentioned elsewhere, I don’t do moderation well, so let’s move straight from a cheap thrill to the ridiculously expensive, shall we? I only own a sample of Amouage’s Lyric, the reason for its absence from my collection becoming abundantly clear as soon as one takes a look at the price of that red bottle (214 Euros for 50 ml, for the record). (Edit: It may be more now.)

It is unfortunate, therefore, that I really like this scent from the infamous Omani perfume house known for their opulent fragrances and aspirational pricing. It’s universally agreed to be a rose-based perfume, but while I certainly detect a dark rose in the centre of things, on my skin it’s more about rich, creamy sandalwood, spices and some incense (Omani incense is supposed to be the best in the world). Lyric is a mix of Arabic inspiration and French technique, a Perfume with a pretty capital P. While it might be too much for many people, I personally find it both comforting and sexy. I like it best when it’s half-gone, after whatever activities one might undertake while wearing a sexy fragrance.

This is probably the reason why I like it both as a perfume and a body cream. Of the latter, too, I only have a sample (no need to explain, I assume?), but if I was filthy rich, I’d buy 10 jars for my home in Marrakech. As a cream, Lyric is less sweet and in my opinion even less rosy – it becomes drier, woodier and more incense-y. It doesn’t function too well as a body cream, which makes the whole thing even more ridiculous (I mean, for 100 Euros one could reasonably expect nice texture and some moisturizing action, right?), but we are so far from rational territory anyway that functionality becomes kind of irrelevant.

A note on availability: doesn’t really matter (see the price above), but it’s sold in Kaubamaja, online and in many fancy perfume shops around the world.

10 Comments

Add yours
  1. 1
    Holly

    These were fun to read, the pics are actually wonderful, and I thank you for sharing them here. You’re right, FB can be a struggle to navigate through. I wrote off Mitsouko a long time ago, but I’ll probably revisit it at some point. Of the Guerlains, I like Apres L’Ondee and Chamade the most. I’m more of a Chanel girl myself, and if I go vintage it’s usually Caron as they’re so quirky. I’m interested to hear your take on Chanel No 5, as it’s one that I can understand the appeal of, but it’s so not me and I’m not sure why. I’m sure you can be much more articulate about it. 🙂

    • 2
      Ykkinna

      There is something for No 5 coming up, from a slightly different angle 🙂 Which Chanels do you like? I wore Mademoiselle in my pre-perfumista days and now I would gladly wear most of the Exclusifs. And I do own a few. When it comes to Guerlains, Apres L’Ondee is my biggest love as well and I do occasionally wear Shalimar when I’m in the mood for it. I must try Jicky again in the parfum concentration, I tried it in Paris once and it still haunts me.

      • 3
        Holly

        I like Chanel No 19 and 22, 31 Rue Cambon, Cristalle, No 19 Poudre, Bois des Iles, and Cuir de Russies. I need to spend some time with the other Les Exclusifs which are floating in my Sample Sea. 🙂

        • 4
          Ykkinna

          I have problems with No 22 (I’ll get there one day…), but love the rest. I absolutely adore Cuir de Russie and Rue Cambon and from the ones you don’t mention, Sycomore, Bel Respiro, La Pausa (doesn’t last, though), Coromandel and I’m sure I’m forgetting something important.

  2. 5
    bardot

    Mitsouko is not a love for me either…I owned a bottle of edt (not vintage) and used it from time to time but gifted it away to someone who REALLY loved it…my favourite Guerlain is L’Heure Bleue….and I love cheap thrills! I think the perfume world has become a bit “snobbish” as I notice that when a cheap thrill is mentioned there are complaints of lack of longevity, chemical smell, too this, too that…but honestly, I have been wearing perfume for over 40 years and many of the new niche an uber-expensive fragrances I have sampled smell strikingly similar to some of the drugstore cheapies I wore in the 1970s! And really, the prices of some of these fragrances are outrageous! I know you can get a high quality and unique perfume without having to pay a lot of money….so much of our wantings are based on the “hype”…..in my day there were no Chanel exculsives….a refill spray of No 22 edt was under forty dollars…..now that same amount of liquid costs , I believe, 160 USD…..so I applaud you for bringing to everyone’s attention that there are indeed lovely fragrances out there that won’t break the bank!

    • 6
      Ykkinna

      I agree with you entirely and I can be guilty of it as well – not snobbishness, exactly, but I do get excited by beautiful packaging and interesting concepts. And I think that to a certain extent it’s fine, it’s OK to enjoy these aspects – as long as I keep in mind that these things are not necessarily in correlation with the quality of the fragrance. What I seriously don’t like is people dismissing perfumes automatically when they are not expensive or stylish enough and looking down at other people’s choices. I also think the perfume pricing is getting out of hand – I don’t have a problem with high prices per se, but if every new niche perfume seems to cost more than a Serge Lutens bell jar (or a Chanel classic in parfum), then I think something is out of proportion.

  3. 9
    bardot

    One last comment I must make (or rant I must make 🙂 !!). I think the perfume industry (including and especially the niche brands and high end like Chanel/Guerlain) have really taken advantage of those of us that are “addicted” to perfume…they keep raising the prices knowing full well that we will continue to buy (even if we have to engage in buying just a sample for four dollars or participating in a split). Many years ago it was unheard of “paying” for a sample….they were handed out freely and readily and happily by an SA knowing that if you took the fragrance home and was allowed to experience it chances are you would come back and buy a full bottle…nowadays the SAs look at you with disdain when you ask for samples and commenters have remarked that ebay had listing of samples for sale that SAs “stole” from the companies they worked for! Recently when I asked for a sample of the new Bond (which I believe is close to three hundred dollar for the larger size) the SA said, point blank “No…either on your skin or on a card” to which I replied “If I am going to spend all of that money on Park Avenue South perfume then I need to sample it at leisure at home on my skin for several days before I decide whether or not to buy it” and I promptly walked away.

    • 10
      Ykkinna

      I believe the pricing follows a very simple general law – if (most) customers are willing to pay more, the brands charge more. Crazy price hikes have not happened only to perfume, but with shoes and bags and beauty products as well. When it’s a general trend, at some point it becomes almost difficult not to go along, as the price is also a marker of luxury and if you have positioned your brand as a luxury one, you cannot be much cheaper than your peers. I have wondered for some time if this logic will make Chanel and Guerlain up the prices of their mainstream classics as well… And don’t get me started on snobby and rude SAs, I get seriously angry about this. I had a similar experience with Keiko Mecheri, once. To be fair, I’ve just had an excellent encounter with a SA in the local Chanel boutique. I marched in to ask if they had Misia already, they did, and the SA gave me two samples in a nice little Chanel paper bag and I didn’t buy a thing.

+ Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.