On Understanding the World
I have been away for more than a week in Indonesia and India. Before you get jealous, let me underline these were work trips with minimal free time and hardly any sleep: I have said before that my job is intense and I’m not joking. This doesn’t change the fact that being able to travel to the other side of the world as part of one’s job is a huge privilege – not just because it’s interesting to see other places (and it’s warm), but because it expands your mind.
What struck me in particular this time, enough to write it up for the blog, is the immense complexity of the world we live in. I was reading a book on Indonesian history before going and while it was an easy, beginner’s book, I had to read it slowly: the country is so vast and diverse and so much has happened in the course of its history that even absorbing the basic facts is no small feat. Especially if one’s understanding of Indonesian history is rather lacking in the first place.
The trip itself only intensified this feeling of richness. I had the chance to visit Bali (where the G20 energy ministers met), Kalimantan/Borneo and Java. All three are completely different from each other – Bali with its beaches and flowers and fruit, Kalimantan’s jungle, oil palms and mines and Jakarta’s smoggy urbanism. I imagine that Sulawesi and Sumatra and Papua/New Guinea are entirely different again. There are more than 17 000 islands, 275 million people and 700 languages. Even flora and fauna do not unite the entire archipelago, divided as they are by the Wallace line.
And then I travelled on to Delhi and India is of course no easier to grasp. With its more than billion people in one big peninsula, it may seem more uniform than the Indonesian islands, but this is deceiving. Indian states vary widely in terms of language, geography and culture. The internal politics as well as geopolitical relations are extremely complex and the history has layers upon layers, often further complicated by ideology.
I know this isn’t news to anyone and the above is not meant to be a lecture, but context to the point (such as it is) of my post. During the trip, I kept wondering how I’m ever going to have even the most basic understanding of other places? As I read A Brief History of Indonesia, as well as Ancient India: Culture of Contradictions and The Loss of Hindustan, I felt that I barely scratchung the surface. That was particularly true of Indonesia, as I had a slightly better knowledge of Indian history going in. But there are about 200 countries in the world and many of them I know much worse than Indonesia.
So how is it possible to be informed about anything, ever? Even if I spend all my time reading and learning about other cultures, I will never get there. And sure, not knowing the history of Honduras isn’t likely to ruin my life or anyone else’s, it just makes me feel bad. But the same question applies also more broadly. How does one form opinions on things happening in the world while being largely ignorant of, frankly, everything? Or professionally, how does one advocate for, say, global clean energy transition without really understanding the economic, social, environmental, technological, political and psychological implications?
I wonder if me struggling with these things so much is impacted by the fact that I come originally from a country of 1.3 million people. While our history and present aren’t without complexity and nuances, it is ultimately graspable and manageable. Or perhaps it’s just the way I’mmmade. Or it’s the result of living in a global, interconnected world saturated with information.
In any case, the trip left me with a strange mood – on one hand exhilerated by new experiences and knowledge, on the other depressed by my own inadequacy. Do you ever get this feeling? Or am I just being silly?
The cover picture is taken in a hotel in Bali. The image below is from an open-pit coal mine in Kalimantan.
Thank you for again a great article. If you permit, I would like to add my personal view.
When I was sixteen I won a scholarship to attend a very idealistic school with students from more than 70 different countries. I had been a good and ambitious (and yes idealistic) teenager in my native Austria, but the school was a shock to my lovely self esteem. I realized that I know absolutely nothing about the world, how other people live, what topics they lose sleep over.
I have lived in Brazil, UK, France, Germany, spent several months in South Africa and I have been a doctor and psychiatrist for almost 15 years. The feeling of knowing nothing is still there, but it has lost its terror, is has been a fuel to my natural curiosity how other people feel, think and live. I have accepted that I will never know THE truth, it makes me sad at times, but it’s ok. I teach my children to be highly skeptical of people who have a seemingly easy solution or know THE answer. Life is so much more complex. Being aware of not knowing and being open to learn from each other. That’s what I think is important.
Dear Gudrun, you are of course absolutely right. The trick is to accept the reality and to use it in a positive way, to motivate, not to despair. I do understand this and sometimes manage to apply it. It works better in my personal life, where I have understood that there is a limit to how much I can read and learn and experience and that’s OK. And as you say, being sad about it sometimes is also OK. Where I really struggle with this though is in my professional life, where I feel not knowing enough has consequences, but it’s also simply impossible to know enough. Or at least enough to meet my standards.
“So how is it possible to be informed about anything, ever?”
It is not possible. No finish line.
To recognize that is good and is wisdom.
As Gudrun said so well being open to learn, to have that attitude is the key. And critical thinking.
You cannot read ALL. Everything written is not The True Story. And you will forget what you’re reading today…
To understand the world… I do not understand myself!
I have indeed come to the sad conclusion that I cannot read EVERYTHING ever written:) But it’s not only/mainly about that, it’s a fear of not understanding enough of the world to be a citizen that contributes more good than she does harm. And more importantly, to do my work in a way that is based on an informed, adequate understanding of things around us. My inability to read all the books about Ancient Mesopotamia only has consequences for me. Me failing to understand certain geopolitical or technological developments can have consequences for many others as well.