The Making of a Witch: Circe by Madeline Miller

The Making of a Witch: Circe by Madeline Miller


When you are very young, every book can be a miracle, if you’re so inclined. It’s always a new world, exciting and unique, something you haven’t experienced before. Your mind is blown and then blown again. Nothing exists but the book in your hands, you are completely absorbed and deaf to the world.

If you keep reading, year after year, some of this magic will eventually evaporate. You’ll see that not all writers really have much new to say, you’ll discover their prejudices and cheap tricks, you’ll realise that some of them don’t even write that well. It’s a specific kind of loss.

It’s not only a loss, of course. Your taste will develop and you’ll appreciate nuances you didn’t notice before, you’ll be able to value things that are deeper and darker and more complex. You’ll realise that making an effort when reading a book is not necessarily a bad thing and can yield amazing rewards. But I don’t know any reader who doesn’t yearn for that feeling of getting completely lost in a book, caught up in a story that simply does not let you go. And that feeling becomes more and more difficult to experience, because your inner critic is always awake and her ear is so attuned by now that nothing escapes her – the clumsy sentence, the stereotypical female character, the lazy plot device, she’ll spot them all a mile away.

Sometimes, however, the Gods are merciful and you read the right book at the right time and it has just the right balance of infectiousness and insight, drama and depth. This happened to me last weekend when I read Circe. I think it often helps when you don’t expect to love a book, you’ll go in maybe too relaxed or overconfident and the book will snare you with its charms. I was hooked from the first sentence and remained hooked until the end.

Circe is, as I’m sure you have guessed (if you haven’t read it yet), a retelling of a Greek myth. Witch on an island, turning men into pigs, lover of Odysseus, you know the story. And while these things do happen in the book, it’s not what it’s about. If you want to read this for the love story between Circe and the Best of the Greeks, you’ll likely to be disappointed, as it takes up rather little of the book. This is a full, rich tale of a woman’s life that does, indeed, include a famous affair, but also a lonely childhood, self-discovery, horrible mistakes, work, motherhood, grief and many kinds of love.

Saying that a book is about female empowerment sounds trite, but the truth is I did feel empowered. There are many things you can enjoy in Circe. The voice is poetic and beautiful and with a touch of epicness, but still modern. The relationships are drawn with such loving care that I fell for everybody Circe fell for (and it’s a special pleasure to see more mature love that feels as romantic – or in this book much more so – as a teenage one). The women are good and bad, shallow, vengeful, weak, loving, monstrous, powerful, smart, lost, found and sometimes all at once. Circe herself is believable and sympathetic and watching her timidness and terror turn into strength is inspiring.

The thing I most identified with was the importance of being yourself, of making something of yourself, something that is impossible – or at least very difficult – to take from you. For Circe, it’s her witchcraft, her carefully honed skills that give her a sense of satisfaction and joy, but also protection and power. It doesn’t mean she loves her work more than she loves her child or that she is never sad or alone, because she has her herbs. But she always has something that is her own.

I don’t know if Circe is what people would call a literary masterpiece, probably not. It is too gripping for that, has too much melodrama and romance, monsters and beauty. Daniel Mandelsohn famously said of Miller’s previous book that it has “the head of a young adult novel, the body of the ‘Iliad’ and the hindquarters of Barbara Cartland” and people have said similar things of Circe. I don’t care. And I’m also done with this casual degrading of everything related to women, even if it’s Barbara Cartland.

It is perfectly possible that had I read this at a different moment in my life, not so desperately needing affirmation and inspiration, I would have seen the book differently as well. I don’t care about that either. Circe kept me up until the early morning and assured me I was a witch, too. Being accused of less than impeccable literary tastes is a very, very small price to pay for that.

PS Greek myths seem to be having a moment. Pictured are the Stephen Fry retellings I’ve already finished, the new Odyssey translation by Emily Wilson, Circe and two modern takes on Antigone that have been recommended to me recently.

8 Comments

Add yours
  1. 1
    Melanie

    You have made me want to read this (and the other new, mythology-related releases). Her Song of Achilles has been on my wishlist for a while. I have had little time to read as my children are still a bit young and seem to demand my attention more whenever I open a book, however, I am feeling hopeful for this summer!

    • 2
      Ykkinna

      It is not easy to keep one’s reading time while also taking care of small children, that’s certainly true. I hope you’ll be able to find some time this summer, though, and I think Circe is well worth trying. Let me know how it goes!

  2. 3
    Jenny

    I’m so glad you liked it. I had zero expectations when I started this one–I still haven’t read Song of Achilles so I didn’t know what all the fuss was about–but like you I was immediately drawn in. I agree the voice is poetic, occasionally elevated, intimate, but it’s imminently readable, I’d even can it a “fun” read. More mythology, please!

    • 4
      Ykkinna

      I haven’t read Song of Achilles either, wondering now if I should. And I agree Circe is fundamentally a fun read (althought not ONLY fun, other things as well), SoA is probably sadder.

  3. 5
    Frances

    I read your recommendation and bought Circe immediately, started reading, read far into the night, and finished it the next day. As for you, it must have been the right book at the right time. I enjoyed it very much. It has echoes of Mary Renault’s style of story telling, but that isn’t necessarily a bad thing. The writing is spare and well-paced,, and I admired both Circe and Penelope for their — what should I call this quality?— acceptance? endurance? both these things, I think. Also, that their love was clear-eyed: they saw the whole of their loved ones, but loved anyway. It is a book with some grace, I think.

    I also bought Song of Achilles, but haven’t enjoyed it as much.

    • 6
      Ykkinna

      Thank you for reporting back! I’m so glad you liked it – you know how it is when you recommend something, the fear of being wrong and causing people to waste their time or worse. The relationship between Circe and Penelope was one of my favourite things in the book.

      Have you finished Song of Achilles by now?

  4. 7
    Eliza

    Skipping between here and your instagram page, where I spied Elif Batuman’s The Idiot – I read it last month and it did exactly what good books do, as you describe here: it took me right into Selin’s world, wholly absorbing and almost magical, but it also took me back to my undergrad days, in a whirl of madness and nostalgia. Just. Absolute. Madness. The lunacy of never needing to sleep and being obsessed with a boy and wondering why lecturers seem to make no sense, ever, while at the same time wanting what they know…It’s very funny, extremely witty, and melancholy in the best way. Also, I’m guessing, irresistible to anyone who remembers the dawn of email, or was a serious-minded arts/humanities student. And can I just say, Barbara Cartland was extremely good at being Barbara Cartland (I’ve read much more of her work than I have of Daniel M’s – who he? – and she was synonymous with the colour pink, goddam) and I bought the Song of Achilles ages ago and will read it sooner rather than later thanks to your review of Miller. Can I also give a shout out to my countryman Colm Toibin and his recent novel House of Names – also in my TBR pile – as he’s generally a very good stylist, cool, astute, but sympathetic, while also telling a really good story (the Oresteia in this case). That Wilson translation got some interesting reviews. My favourite is the E.V. Rieu Penguin Classics one from the 1940s – I guess it’s somewhat stately – but I like the sound of Wilson’s updating.

    • 8
      Ykkinna

      Thank you for your thoughts on The Idiot – I haven’t read it myself yet, but a couple of people whose taste I trust have been happy with it and now you too. So I’m inclined to give it a go. I do remember the dawn of the e-mail, after all 🙂 If you read Song of Achilles, let me know what you think! I’ve got so many great book lined up for summer, I really hope I’ll have more time to read from now on. With the World Cup ending, work quieting down and a lot of blog stuff taken care of (I shot many outfits in Tallinn last weekend), there should be.

+ Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.