10 Fragrances I Cannot Live Without
The title is of course a lie – I am currently out of at least two perfumes mentioned here and I am still very much alive (although perhaps this explains my recent health troubles…). But a follower on Instagram asked me to provide such a list and I thought: why not? I have enough experience with wearing and paying attention to perfume by now to select scents that I’m reasonably confident I’ll not change my mind about any time soon.
It is not the list of my current favourites and it’s not even a list of what I think are the best fragrances ever. I wanted to be as faithful as I could to the task and I have therefore chosen only things that I either have repurchased or plan to repurchase as soon as I run out. To put things in context, I repurchase fragrances very rarely. First, that’s because I hardly ever run out of anything, as I have what most people would consider a large collection: about 60 full bottles, a number of decants and travel sprays and hundreds of samples. Second, my instinct is usually to buy new stuff rather than rebuy something familiar. This is changing to a certain extent now, as I try to focus more on things I absolutely love, but there are frankly very many excellent perfumes out there. In any case, if I have bought a perfume twice or thrice, it’s a clear sign that my feelings are serious.
So here we go, in no particular order:
31 Rue Cambon, Chanel. It is interesting (well, it is for me, I don’t think it’s particularly fascinating to anyone else) that while I am lukewarm about Chanel’s best known perfumes – Number 5, Coco and the newer additions of Mademoiselle*, Gabrielle and Chance -, I love the brand’s Les Exclusifs line. There aren’t really any I don’t like within the 18-scent collection and there are at least five that I adore. 31 Rue Cambon summarises everything I appreciate about Chanel fragrances: the elegance, the sophistication, the exquisite iris, the touch of masculinity, the quality. There is no better fragrance for the office if you want to appear effortlessly confident and capable (if your budget doesn’t stretch to the exclusifs prices, No 19 has a similar vibe). It is assertive without being overwhelming and simply has such backbone. Plus it is also gorgeous, in a complex, slightly aloof way.
Féminité du Bois, Serge Lutens. Those who have closely studied the cover image of this post already know that instead of Serge Lutens’s classic Feminite du Bois, it includes in fact its close relative Bois de Violette. Because indeed, after draining two bottles of FdB, I went for its sister instead and as they cover very similar territory, I haven’t yet gotten around to replacing the original. I will, though. Feminite du Bois is possibly the best woody fragrance ever created; it’s certainly my favourite. The most prominent note here is cedarwood and while I often find it quite screechy, FdB is as sumptuous and beautifully blended as is possible to get. Plum, peach, sandalwood, rose and violet round the sharper corners of cedar and cinnamon and ginger add warmth. In Bois de Violette, the violet note has been played up, resulting in a sweeter and gentler, but equally beautiful creation. My only worry is that as Lutens continues to reformulate his fragrances, Feminite du Bois will keep moving away from what it originally was – and I haven’t even tried the very first version that was launched under the Shiseido brand.
London, Tom Ford. This is the darkest perfume on this list – smoky, leathery, woody, tarry, spicy. It has pretty much every deep note you can think of: from coffee to inscense, from musk to oud. I don’t find it hard to wear, however, which I suspect is partly because I like Ford’s style (this is not his las fragrance on this list) and partly because I seem to like this sort of fragrances. Nanban by Arquiste is similar and could have been on this list, if I wasn’t only half-way through my first bottle. The wonderful Anubis by Papillon Perfumes falls into the same category as well. London is of course something that in traditional terms would be classified as a (hyper)masculine fragrance, which only makes me like it more. If you are a woman, it can be used to accentuate a menswear-inspired/badass look or as a counterpoint to something uber feminine. If you are a man, well, just get it.
Mimosa & Cardamom, Jo Malone. I buy Jo Malone fragrances often: I find many of them lovely and extremely easy to wear, and I am not mentally equipped to wear something achingly intricate or powerfully hardcore every single day. The other reason I am fond of them is that Jo Malone does 30ml bottles, which is a god-send for someone like me: I usually don’t need more anyway. The only large-size Malone I have ever bought has been Mimosa & Cardamom, after I finished the small one in a few months. I knew that I’ll have no trouble going through it, because I absolutely love wearing it. It is a happy, sunny scent, a wonderfully creamy yellow floral with touches of fruit and spice. There is a bit of sweetness, but it’s no vanilla-bomb. It is probably one of my most complimented fragrances, as it’s easy to like and it never overpowers. Like most of the JM cologne line, it is not designed to be a long-lasting fragrance (if you want the lightness of a cologne, you usually have to sacrifice some longevity), which never bothers me – one does not go to JM for staying power**. But in case it’s important for you, be forewarned.
Après l’Ondée , Guerlain. When I comes to fragrance, I am much more of a Chanel girl than I am a Guerlain one. But there is one Guerlain classic that I love and never want to be without: Apres l’Ondee, the masterpiece form 1906. There are many beautiful reviews about this scent, usually evoking a romantic garden after the rain and/or gentle melancholy. This is all well and good, but the only thing you really need to know is that it’s pretty. I can fully understand people who do not fancy my stark irises or shocking concoctions of leather and tar. What I do not understand is people who don’t think Apres l’Ondee smells like the essence of prettiness. It is the delicate sum of dewy violets, puffs of mimosa (do you see a theme emerging here?), anise bonbons and rose-scented powder. To me, it descends trends and tastes. There are constant rumors of Guerlain discontinuing Apres l’Ondee and I will never forgive them if they do.
Iris Silver Mist, Serge Lutens. I mentioned stark iris fragrances in the previous paragraph and there’s none starker than ISM, the mother of all irises. I love iris fragrances and enjoy all variations of the note: I like it cold and severe and mixed with vetiver or green notes; I like it tempered with fruity accords; I like it with its sweeter cousin violet; I like it with leather, with woods, with everything. It is, in my view, the most refined note there is – adding iris to a fragrance gives it instant class. ISM is not my most-worn iris, as it’s a demanding fragrance: those with deeper interest in perfume know that it includes a massive dose of orris butter made from the roots of iris plants***. It is one of the most expensive perfume ingredients and usually used sparingly. In ISM, it’s abundant and that’s why it can smell too rooty, too uncompromising for some. I think it’s stunning and every time I smell it, I am almost surprised how stunning I find it. I will never be without it.
Fleur de Chine, Tom Ford. Tom Ford is generally not known for refined understatement. Oh, he can do polished like nobody’s business and he is sophisticated, but he’s also sexy and bold. You should, however, not underestimate Tom Ford. While I admit I have a weakness for his over-priced, too large and infuriatingly unpredictable line of fragrances****, I would confidently recommend Fleur de Chine to the most committed Ford-phobes. It is a refined abstract floral that I have in the past described smelling like what I imagine soaps in heaven would smell like. I still cannot come up with a better decription. It is gently powdery and somehow both old school and modern at the same time. Out of all the perfumes on this list, it’s the most difficult to describe in terms of notes, as the bouquet of florals (perhaps magnolias and peonies and jasmine) and a bowl of delicate fruits are wrapped in aldehydes that give it the blurry, luminously soapy finish I so love. Of course, considering all this, Tom Ford has discontinued it and I only have a decant, as you can see from the photo. I live in constant hope of its return.
Lyric Woman, Amouage. When Fleur de Chine does opulence with a light touch, Lyric goes all in. It throws everything at you – roses and jasmine, sandalwood and incense, cinnamon and tonka bean. Despite all of its velvety richness, I don’t find it suffocating at all. It’s also not, at least on me, a rose-dominated fragrance, although it’s usually described as such. It’s an exquisitely creamy, luscious oriental perfume that remains the only full-size Amouage bottle that I own (I would probably own more, but they are ruinously expensive). How it doesn’t collapse under its own weight is rather remarkable. In my mind, it’s in the same category with another complex rose scent, Neela Vermeire’s Mohur extrait. I absolutely love the latter and probably would pronounce the better scent. But I feel that when I run out of both, I would replace Lyric first.
Lumière Blanche, Olfacive Studio. The trouble with these kind of lists is that they tend to be rather boring: by default, they aren’t going to contain anything very new or interesting and at least in my case, the top 10 is heavily skewed towards established brands that I have loved for a long time. Lumiere Blanche is, I’m afraid, the only truly niche scent on this list. With its creaminess and soft woods, it has an affinity with Mimosa & Cardamom and Lyric and to a certain extent even Feminite du Bois. But in its own category, it surpasses them all – it’s the most comforting scent I own. It smells like almond milk spiced with cardamom in a sandalwood cup and there is no day where I couldn’t or wouldn’t wear it, if I had to. There is nothing else I’d rather smell on my cashmere sweater the next day.
Cuir de Russie, Chanel. As above, so below: let’s finish with another Chanel. I could have picked differently, gone for the extraordinary Sycomore, my favourite vetiver; the sadly discontinued Cristalle EDT or the lovely Paris-Deauville. But if I can only have two, it has to be Cuir de Russie. I have just bought a new bottle and am getting used to it again. As the name indicates, it’s a leather fragrance and unapologetically so. But because it’s Chanel, it’s of course a very elegant leather. If you smell Cuir de Russie and 31 Rue Cambon side by side, you’ll notice a family resemblance, partly down to the iris that plays an important part in both. CdR makes me think of saddle soap, although I have never smelled an actual saddle – or any other leather object – treated with it. It’s the classic Chanel aldehydes that create this soapy effect on top of the darker layer underneath. A perfectly balanced blend of tobacco and leather and the classic Chanel florals, Cuir de Russie is a perfume for the ages.
Do you have any fragrances you don’t want to be without? I’d be sincerely curious to know.
*Full disclosure: I went through a Coco Mademoiselle phase in my early twenties, it was my first work fragrance, but while I can see why I liked it back then, I really cannot wear it any longer.
**The Intense line – a later addition – is a different story and something you might want to try if you like the JM aesthetic, but want something stronger. For me, it often negates the reasons I gravitate towards JM in the first place.
***This also explains why iris fragrance don’t really smell floral. For a softer, more flowery touch, violet is often added, as it shares some fragrance compounds with iris.
****There are constant launches and abrupt discontinuations. And then sometimes scents are brought back again. It is frustrating.
This was a good read. I haven’t tried any of the fragrances listed because I tend to prefer gourmand / resin notes. I know you’re not fond of amber (or possibly gourmands going by your list), so be warned. In no particular order:
African Leather – Memo
Akkad – Lubin
Bal d’Afrique – Byredo
Benjoin Bohème – Diptyque
Faisa – Ramón Monegal
Grand Soir – Maison Francis Kurkdjian
Kalemat Black – Arabian Ôud
La Danza Delle Libellule – Nobile 1942
L’Air du Désert Marocain – Tauer
Lira – Xerjoff
Musc Ravageur – Frederic Malle
Neroli blanc Intense – Au Pays de la Fleur d’Oranger
Ôud Bouquet – Lancôme
Poets of Berlin – Vilhelm Parfumerie
Gourmands aren’t my first port of call, but I do wear them (same with ambers, actually, I just don’t gravitate towards them). I really like the first three perfumes on your list, for example! Lumière Blanche could probably be described as a gourmand, but it’s not one of those big oriental ones. I wonder if you’d like Lyric as well, or some of the other Amouages?
And I should smell Poets of Berlin, I was thinking about it recently.
Love your “can’t be without ” perfume selection and the honesty of your approach to the subject.
I often think that there is so many perfumes I can’t imagine to live without and obsessively repurchase as soon as there is only few spritz in the bottle…
But 10? Noooo more like 50! But I will try. Random order.
1. Hermes Eau des merveilles
2. Ys Uzac Pohadka
3. Olfactive studio (ha!) Ombre Indigo although Chambre Noire comes close and I’ve got 3 bottles just in case…
4. Creed Royal Oud
5. Nasomatto Baraonda
6. Amouage Interlude
7. ELO Like this
8. Olivier Durbano Heliotrope
9. Tom Ford Vert d’encens
10. Jo Malone Cade & cedarwood – extremely frustrating as it was limited edition and only comes in 30ml bottle. Managed to snap 5 bottles but down to my last two now.
Oh, what an intriguing list! I don’t recall Ombre Indigo that well, but Chambre Noire I’ve liked since it was launched. Like This is lovely and the entite TF vert series was/is good. And I have a couple of JM faves that are never coming back, so I feel you.
Uh, I want Chanel’s rue Cambon now. I’ve just put it in my cart and sleep on it for a night. If Corona is still on tomorrow I’ll buy it.
Thank you for this lovely post. I love reading your thoughts. Hope you and your family are well.
hugs,
Gudrun
Did you get it? It is an amazing fragrance, so I’m kinda hoping you did…
We are all good here, a bit tired from everything, but healthy and well. Hope you are fine, too.
I’m a fan of everything here, the only exception being Olfactive Studio, which I have simply never tried (must hunt a sample as I’m curious). On a related front, I’m excited and a little afraid to smell the newest Chanel because I hear it has echoes of Shalimar, Cuir de Russie, aaaand Coromandel. I love those, truly, and I hope I can convince myself that I don’t need another iteration of them. However, my perfume buying in lockdown has probably doubled, and my willpower is generally no match for Chanel 🙂
Yes, I in fact described Le Lion as a cross between Shalimar and Cuir de Russie, so you might be in trouble. I don’t like it as much as CdR, but it’s a great fragrance. Much bolder than anything Chanel has released recently, which makes me appreciate it so much, even if I don’t necessarily want to buy it myself. Would be excellent on a man, too.
Also, Lumière Blanche is really worth trying, I think they sell samples, too.
It doesn’t happen too often for me with other people’s lists, so I want to comment that I like and own in one from or the other 5 of your 10 picks. And I’m a big Jo Malone fan. And I don’t like No 5 or Chance (I do like the older, but not vintage, version of Coco).
On a separate note, how recent is your ISM? I heard it was significantly reformulated in the last several years. I haven’t tried the newer version, but the person who reported it wasn’t saying it as a criticism – the opposite, she liked the new formula better. But she didn’t like the original one, so her opinion might be different from the one of an original ISM’s fan.
Thank you for commenting, I’m really glad to hear this. Not that people have to like the same things, of course, but there is something genuinely moving in finding these overlaps with people on the other side of the world.
My ISM is not new, I bought it at least five years ago if not more. I am pretty sure there has been some serious reformulating going on at Lutens, I’m somewhat afraid to try the current versions.
I love all your lists, but it’s funny how this one inspired readers to respond in kind. Because we can, I guess, whereas far fewer can think of 5 Korean skin care items they tried recently 😉 Anyway, here’s mine:
Chanel Cristalle EDT – I didn’t know it was discontinued! This was my first perfume love when I was in college and I can’t imagine being without it. Ordered a bottle from the Chanel website, which says it is “back ordered.” We’ll see.
31 Rue Cambon
Chanel No. 19
Ormonde Woman
Ormonde Jayne Ta’if
Bronze Goddess
Hermes Osmanthe Yunnan
Neela Vermeire Trayee
L’Artisan The Pour Une Ete
Jo Malone English Oak and Hazelnut
Thank you! We have a huge overlap in our favourites: Trayee, Ormonde Woman and Bronze Goddess could be on my list as well and I like everything you’ve included.
Regarding the feedback: I think that there is a lovely group of readers who found me through perfume and have been here since the beginning – and they almost always react when I write about perfume. Which is truly heartwarming. Some of my other readers who have found me through other routes are probably more likely to have extensive knowledge of Korean skincare than Ormonde Jayne…
Point taken. I came for the perfume talk, and stayed for the fine writing on Korean skincare, Estonian fashion, books, food, and everything else. Thank you for all of it.
I have spent hours trying to work this one out (the most fun I’ve had on the internet in many months) and I no longer know how to decide. Is it the scent, its associations, what it represents, was it a gift, how long have I known it (the older, the more treasured) – I thought my wardrobe was my main emotional complex, but my perfume collection has even murkier depths! I love your list as many of these are already favourites (because I’ve read your blog avidly ;-)) especially the Chanels, Serges and Guerlain. Here’s my attempt at 10: I would prefer not to be without Clarins Eau Dynamisante, as a decades-old workhorse, my two biggest Guerlains, Chamade and Nahema, other good Chanels: (5, 19, 22, Bois des Iles) and, er, as many Serges as I can smuggle in – Vitriol d’Oeillet and La Fille de Berlin as top choices. Room for one more, so maybe…Estee Lauder Youth Dew? I wasn’t expecting that to appear, and I’m surprised not to see Shalimar (most worn) or anything by Jean Claude Ellena. The Clarins is really my only repurchase, as I tend to eke out a beloved bottle rather than buy another one, as I expect it will never smell the same the second time round – too many variables in the meantime!
I am flattered to have triggered this amount of soul searching:) But I think it can be fun, to analyse one’s taste and preferences as if they are worthy of the most rigorous analysis! And in many ways, they of course are.
In any case, this is a lovely list. Youth Dew is a pretty surprising entry indeed, as I think we have a large overlap in our tastes and this is one perfume that I don’t really enjoy. But that’s exactly what makes these exercises interesting!
Right now I would say Chanel Sycomore and Chanel 22 are my top fragances. Sad story I only had samples but those I would pick to be in my vanity forever.
I find No 22 a bit difficult, but I have a lot of respect for it. Sycomore I love.
I like quite a few of your picks, but moreover I agree with the general commentary on Chanel, Guerlain, TF. Funnily enough I find the perfumes I cannot leave behind are mostly Frederique Malle… especially Lys Mediterranee, L’Eau d’Hiver and Portrait of a Lady. I detest Jo Malone (something about the marketing image, I have to admit) but really love those I have tried of Les Exclusifs. And I too have been lost to the world in an irrelevant cloud of Coco Mademoiselle for a while…
I used to be very dismissive of Jo Malone and I admit the fragrances aren’t masterpieces the way Malles or Chanels are. But the truth is I really, really like many JM scents. I think my favourite Malle is actually the not-very-popular Une Fleur de Cassie.
I’m late to comment, I know. Your list is great. If you want to smell the original Feminite du Bois by Shiseido, let me know. I have it.
I’m also afraid to smell the newest Lutens. I ran out of his FdB and I’m hunting vintages now. I recently got Tubereuse Criminele and Musc Koublai Khan.
I don’t repurchase perfumes. Only exceptions: Passage d’enfer (L’Artisan Parfumeur) and Feminite du Bois.
My list:
1. Marienbad – Prada Olfactories
2. Shanghai Lily – Tom Ford
3. Vanilla and Anise – Jo Malone
4. Spanish Veil – Edward Bess
5. Feminite du Bois – Shiseido or older Lutens version
6. Passage d’Enfer – L’artisan Parfumeur
7. Marron Chic – Nez a Nez
8. Myths – Amouage
9. Mon Cuir – Monegal
10. White Suede – Tom Ford
Not purcahsed as a full bottle yet: Orris Tattoo – Parle Moi de Parfum (I think it will become a staple) & Gaiac Close your Eyes – Miller et Bertaux.
I should definitely try Lumiere Blanche!
Oh, what a wonderful list! I really must get that bottle of Marienbad, it is so special and great for autumn. Plus it’s very much a slightly obscure classic short story in perfume form, which I appreciate. (And I associate it with you!) Vintage Tubereuse Criminelle sounds absolutely fantastic. I feel that it’s too much to ask for some original FdB, but perhaps you can let me sniff it when I next come to Greece…