The Future of Tolerance

The Future of Tolerance


It was 1998 and I was on my way to Lübeck, upon the invitation of Germany’s young social democrats – to witness the general elections and eventually, Gerhard Schröder’s defeat of Helmut Kohl. As both I and the Estonian social democrats were poor, I arrived with what I believe was a pretty shabby cargo ship. Most of my memories of that trip have faded, but I do recall that the border guards clearly thought I was an Eastern-European prostitute.

This didn’t make me as angry as it should have. Partly because I was more worried about getting into the country than about my reputation; partly because my feminist sensibilities weren’t yet fully formed; but mostly because I was 18 and a virgin at the time and found the suspicion pretty hilarious. That said, I felt ashamed and uneasy and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that this is the only aspect of the visit I can clearly remember today. The reason I bring it up is however not related to my late sexual development, but to the refugee crisis. This (the latter) is such a sensitive subject with so many nuances that I will refrain from activating the full rant mode, but allow me two thoughts.

I find it astonishing that many Estonians and our neighbours fail to see the parallels between how we were treated – and sometimes still are treated – by richer, older democracies, and how we are now treating refugees. And it astonishes me that while we are convinced that it’s our right to work in Finland, to study in UK, to do business in US, to live in France, to spend 3 months hanging out in Thailand, we deny the right of shelter to people fleeing war. Not to mention our scorn for people who are not facing certain death, but “just looking for a better life”. When I hear this from Estonians living in London, my capacity for empathy is entirely exhausted.

The two main conversations in Europe today are about terrorism and refugees and whether justified or not, the arguments about both tend to end up as discussions about Islam. I am an atheist and don’t have particularly warm feelings towards any of the institutionalised religions. But it’s obvious that my understanding of Christianity is much deeper than my knowledge of Islam. As an immigrant living in Brussels, it’s high time to make an effort to be more informed: if there is one thing I believe in life, it’s that more knowledge is better than less knowledge. If you feel something similar, here are four easy places to start:

1. Islam and the Future of Tolerance by Sam Harris and Maajid Nawaz. This is an easy, enlightening read, a write-up of a conversation between a Western atheist and a former Islamic fundamentalist. It asks if Islam can be the religion of peace, where radicals come from and what we can do to prevent this. It’s not comprehensive by any means, but that’s all well and good for our purposes here. I appreciate the idea of such a dialogue and the attempt to establish the playing field and maybe, if we are lucky, to find some common ground. I didn’t agree with everything in the book (mostly I disagreed with Harris), but it helped enormously with structuring my confused thinking about Islam. I now want to read Nawaz’s Radical as well.

2. Islamic History: A Very Short Introduction by Adam J Silverstein. This is a wonderful introduction to the history of Islam from the wonderful Oxford University Press series. It manages to be both academically rigorous and a joy to read. What makes it especially valuable in the current context is that it explains why and how the past of Islam is important for its present and future. In the same series, there is also an introduction to the Koran – a more technical book, but worth reading as well.

3. Laughing all the way to the Mosque by Zarqa Nawaz. If you don’t know anyone who’s Muslim and you’re more interested in what it means to be one, rather than Islam in the more abstract sense, this book could be a good entry point. The author is a Canadian comedian who created Little Mosque on the Prairie, the hit television show about the life of local Muslims. The book is funny and light and often insightful. I’m fully aware that it isn’t representative of most Muslim experience in the world, but one needs to start somewhere. And it might be helpful to start in a place where you don’t feel totally lost.

4. In the Shadow of the Sword by Tom Holland. I hesitated for a long time about including this examination of the origins of Islam. First of all, it isn’t a good starting point. Not because it’s difficult to get into – Holland is a great, witty writer – , but because Holland’s theories are controversial (not only for Muslims) and it’s best to confront them with at least some basic knowledge. It’s also not among his best works and I found him much stronger sketching broader trends – like the rise of monotheism – than on Islam specifically. The main reason it’s on the list is the conversation it sparked, the reactions and reviews that you can easily find on the Internet. And it’s still a fascinating book, despite the shortcomings.

5. The Bible. You didn’t see this coming, did you? Every time someone talks about the violence and backwardness of Islam, I recommend reading the Bible. Religions have changed and will continue to change. For why this is relevant and offers hope, see book no 1 on the list.

Enjoy all these with a cup of Omani tea and halva.

Books on Islam

6 Comments

Add yours
  1. 3
    Holly

    I’m so glad you’ve done this post.

    I was reading it yesterday as the events in California played out, and I wondered about prescience. I thought of you in Brussels in your feathered LBD, Fleur de Chine, and the lovely meal you served after you had written this. I thought of your guests, and what they might say about America and guns and Islam and terrorism at their remove from here. I thought about your daughter and what sort of world it will be when she is the age you are now. I wondered about the value of pacifism and intelligence, and whether or not we humans are actually any different in any fundamental way than during other epochs. The Talking Heads song “Once in a LIfetime” played in my head for a few moments, and I recalled the lovely poem by Rumi, part of which goes as follows:

    Outside beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing,
    there is a field.
    I’ll meet you there.

    I could go on in the same vein, but I’m not sure what I what to say. I simply don’t know what to think about so many things that we have done here on earth. I’m not quite speechless, but I am finding it all rather stunning. It’s nice to have your list of books available to help me focus, and I look forward to reading them all. Thank you.

    • 4
      Ykkinna

      I sometimes think of Europe before the world wars and how people didn’t seem to realize at all what was about to happen. In hindsight, you think that so many lived in a type of collective denial, continuing their lives like nothing was wrong. But then again – what should one do? Stop living one’s life? And so it goes, feathers and guns, lockdown and Fleur the Chine.

      The gun control issue is something I and many of my European friends find very difficult to understand. We know why it’s culturally significant, but I must admit that the laxness of the control really does seem criminal to me. It’s not like it’s impossible to own a gun in Estonia or Sweden – if you are sane and grown-up, it’s in fact pretty easy. It’s just not quite the same as buying a croissant.

      I’m thinking that as you read so widely, these books might be too basic for you, but yiu are the best judge of that, of course. And I loved that snippet from Rumi.

  2. 5
    SophieC

    Thank you for this interesting and thought provoking suggested list. Academically rigorous and being a joy to read are a delight when found together, and I shall make time to read the Silverstein book, as well as Tom Holland’s. I must admit it seems verging on impossible to make sense of the current multi stranded debate through any normal analysis, and yet it seems to mean it is even more important to make at least some sense of it. Only through some level of understanding, both of the roots of the refugee crisis and Islam, which is currently so debated, can we hope to (in my view) achieve some sort of equilibrium.

    • 6
      Ykkinna

      I agree, it seems quite hopeless most of the time. But educating oneself, even if it’s just a little, does offer some feeling of control. I enjoyed Silverstein a lot – the book is slim, but it sketched a general outline of Islam for me and made it easier to explore further. Victoria from BdJ also recommended No God but God by Reza Askan, something I definitely plan to read.

+ Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.